Document Type

Book Review

Publication Date

2006

Abstract

Against the grain of much contemporary Christian theology, Christopher Insole’s The Politics of Human Frailty takes on the challenge of theologically defending political liberalism. Specifically, he defends a strand of political liberalism ‘informed by the theological conviction that the human person is a creature incapable of its own perfection, although nonetheless called to and made for this perfection’ (p. vii). Insole, University Lecturer in Philosophy of Religion at the University of Cambridge, attends to philosophers and theologians primarily in the British tradition, but also on the American side. Insole advances his argument mostly through readings of other authors. Positively, Insole reads both early liberals, such as Edmund Burke, and (more surprisingly) contemporary philosophers, such as John Rawls, as thinkers with whom Christians need have no quarrel. Those who come up for criticism in the book are not contemporary liberals who are hostile to religion, but communitarian-minded philosophers, theologians, and politicians—from early American evangelicals to the contemporary Radical Orthodox theologians—who would impose on society a grand plan for the common good. In the Augustinian worldview that Insole commends, such grand planning is a road to ruin, for it soon runs roughshod over human individuality. Political thought and institutions must instead be sensitive to our fallen condition.

Comments

Authors Reusing Their Own Work

SAGE Journal authors are able to use their article in certain circumstances without any further permission. The chart above includes common requests and an explanation of which ‘version’ of the article can be used in each circumstance.

  • Version 1 – original submission to the journal (before peer review)
  • Version 2 – original submission to the journal with your revisions after peer review, often the version accepted by the editor
  • Version 3 – copy-edited and typeset proofs and the final published version
upload my article to my institution repository or department website Version 2